To Boot New York

Great shoe. Taking a bit of time to break in, and only comes in one width. Looks fantastic and shines up well. You can take it to Nordstrom and get it stretched if it's a bit too narrow for your foot. I have a bit of a wide foot, so that was necessary, and now the shoe is very comfortable.

Looks great. needed a shoe horn to easily slide on but once on were true to size. High quality materials and finish.

This shoe made a squeaking noise. It's a good looking shoe, but it's not worth the risk that the squeak would not go away after breaking it in. Time to boot To Boot New York Franklin and try something else.

These are very stylish shoes. I had high hopes they would be great shoes to wear out with jeans etc. They look great in person. Unfortunately, I found them utterly devoid of any cushion whatsoever, esp in the forefoot. I thought "brick sole" referred only to the color. Turns out that description aptly conveys the cushion of the sole as well, at least for the pair I received and returned.

I love this boot. When I was looking at To Boot New York boots, I actually ordered the Heron model, but when it arrived the toe was a little too pointy for my likes. (Despite the photos/video on Zappos, I didn't really notice it until I tried on an actual pair.) So I returned the Heron for the Hawthorne, and I'm quite happy. One thing I liked about the Heron, though, was the all-leather sole, whereas the Hawthorne has a rubber sole. I normally wear a 9.5 - 10, so I went down to a 9 with the To Boot, and this is the right fit. Actually, it's just a smidge too large, but I know that going down to a 8.5 would be too small. This is a very good boot to wear with jeans and other jean-like pants.

Take a few days to break in, then are comfortable. The sole seems very durable, however leather does not.

This product is a real eye catching item. When I go to Nordstrom I always have to stop and admire the shoe I would buy it but just can't afford the price. I'm sure my wearing it would entice many men to own one. I guess I will lust have to keep salivating when I see it at the store.

Not only do they look great, they are very warm and the most comfortable pair of boots I've ever worn.

EJ's full of it. These are 100% nicer than an allen edmonds. AE is junk in comparison...These are in line with prada and gucci and certainly magli.

I had a few pairs by To Boot before so I was looking forward to wearing these. Unfortunately, they were much stiffer than I was accustomed to from this company.I had to return them.

This is a nice style, and they are very comfortable. They seemed to be good boots for walking to the train and then to the office and back. However they are poorly made and within a few weeks the right heel pulled away from the upper. That was very disappointing! I would not recommend these boots for people who plan to use them for walking.

Very comfortable out of the box. Lighter weight than I expected, but feels high-quality. The color is a little lighter and oranger than I expected, and the burnishing is quite high-contrast -- a little too much so for my taste. But it is still a very good looking shoe, suitable for everything from jeans to suits (on the casual side).

This boot is absolutely gorgeous! Ordered a 10 but too big...but the quality look & feel is amazing. Wish they had the 9.5.

These are absolutely great shoes. The fit is phenomenal and I get compliments whenever I wear them especially with jeans!

I bought this shoe in Black last April for my wedding. I must say the shoe is well built and comfortable. It has a '20s appeal to it. I got several compliments. I was quite impressed with the quality of the rubber sole instead of the leather sole. The rubber stands up just as well and is just as durable. Although , you can't take anything away from the leather heel but the price. Overall 5 stars.

Very, very nice shoe! They're well made and very comfortable!

The heel completely deteriorates within the first 2 months and shockingly poor quality heel for the price.

Beautiful boot. Unfortunately fit was a full size larger than marked. Somebody goofed.

Great looking suede casual boot. Quality appears to be on par with other To Boot New York products. However, it fits very large. I've experienced this with other To Boot shoes as well. I returned the pair I ordered and will try a full size smaller.

I have been looking for a double monk that did not cost a mint. This one costs a bit more than I usually pay for Too Boot, but it is a good buy, and I did not have to be concerned that it would sell out.